Thursday, January 3, 2013

Book VI Reflection

The army in Book VI, still remains completely obedient under all circumstances, but there seems to be a change within them. They seem stronger and more passionate than they were in the very beginning, which is most likely because of their position in the way. They still, however, flee when they are outnumbered or at a disadvantage in battle. They do not fight until the death, as they seem to value their lives more than their honor to their country. This is understandable, because it makes much more sense than sacrificing yourself when you know your death will not mean anything. The Romans still, in both situations win a battle afterwards that somewhat makes up for their defeats. When they have calvary on their side, they fight well, but without it they are utterly helpless.
Caesar in this book still holds up his image of a wonderful leader, but I now think I see his flaw. He trusts very easily and wants to settle things peacefully as often as he can. I don't necessarily know if this is considered a flaw, as it is probably pretty wise, but often, he sees people turn on him due to his trust in them. Next, I'm a little confused by Caesar's character as I'm not sure if he's in it for the glory of battle, protecting Rome, or the property and wealth he gains from triumph. Maybe he looked to present himself this way? Aloof and mysterious, but still very commanding. I've also noticed that Caesar's character seems a little different in this book than book I, because he seems much more ready and eager for battle than he did then, but then again he does stop to give the whole history spiel. Maybe it's a steady progressions throughout all of the books that I've just missed. Furthermore, he's taking prisoners and hostages much more readily and demanding than he was before, and I'm not quite sure why that is.
There are no significant speeches in this book; however, there are a couple little ones. For example, the one given by Labienus, about readying for battle. It seems that when there are more speeches in a chapter, there is less action, and vice versa. There is little need for words in war, other than commands and preparing for battle, so in reflection, this topic was probably not the smartest idea. I'm not really feeling it anymore anyway, as I'm much more interested in the other two, but maybe I'll find a really great speech in Book VII and be drawn back to it.

No comments:

Post a Comment